★★★★ | Into The Great Wide Open | Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers | MCA
Review by Parke Puterbaugh
Rolling Stone #608 — July 11, 1991
Into The Great Wide Open started out as potentially another Tom Petty solo record, but it eventually became a full-scale collaboration with his longtime backup band, the Heartbreakers. This shift in Petty’s conception of the album enabled him to combine the unduplicable power of a long-standing band of rock & roll confederates with the new directions he has pursued with Jeff Lynne, the new album’s coproducer and Petty’s fellow Traveling Wilbury. In its best moments, the result sounds like a cross between Full Moon Fever and Damn the Torpedoes and features the most focused and resonant lyrics Petty has ever written.
Employing spare, deceptively simple rhymes in attractive pop settings, Petty sings about the failings, compromises and existential emptiness that underlie the American dream as it staggers, violent and overfed, into the Nineties. His characters range from the compulsive materialists of “All the Wrong Reasons” to the rockin’, rollin’ Hollywood hotshots of “Into the Great Wide Open,” On the latter, the boundless promise of the title is undercut by a minor-keyed intimation of the pot of fool’s gold that await one tattooed dreamer at the end of the rock & roll rainbow: “His leather jacket had chains that would jingle/They both met movie stars, partied and mingled/Their A&R man said, ‘I don’t hear a single’/The future was wide open.” Petty’s protagonist is not just a rebel without a cause; he’s “a rebel without a clue.”
On this album, Petty seldom calls into the pained yowl so evident on Let Me Up (I’ve Had Enough), his most recent outing with the Heartbreakers. These songs are rendered for the most part in the calm voice of someone who has emerged from a soulful bout of contemplation with a new perspective. Petty may at times sound uninvolved and a little smug in the casual manner of those boys’ nights out with the Wilburys, but his cool approach actually springs more from the realization that pulpit-pounding fervor isn’t the only way to get a message across. His message, though, isn’t very reassuring — and sometimes it’s downright cheerless. Petty’s characters rue their fate with a desolation reminiscent of Bruce Springsteen’s darker fables. In “Kings Highway,” Petty sings, “There’s gotta be something left for us to believe,” while “The Dark of the Sun” — a brilliant oxymoron for the impending eclipse of all that once seemed so radiant — frets about “days of great confusion … days of wondering why.” On “All or Nothin’,” smog-covered Los Angeles becomes a metaphor for a nation of hyperactive overachievers choking on greed and technology. Petty sings, with taunting, apocalyptic undertones, “So keep one eye on the weather/You had it good, you wanted better.”
Though the first half of Into the Great Wide Open could stand as a Petty solo showcase, the band’s involvement becomes crucial as the record progresses. As Petty expresses doubt in increasingly passionate terms, the band’s intensity drives “Out in the Cold” and “Too Good to Be True” to riveting climaxes. Their union is firmly welded in three songs that close the album — “You and I Will Meet Again,” “Makin’ Some Noise,” and “Built to Last” — testaments, respectively, to the saving virtues of friendship, rock & roll and conjugal love. “Built to Last” is a buoyant homage to the sweet, soulful sway of classics like “Stand by Me” and “Up on the Roof” that ultimately finds homage — and maybe a little hope — in this simple statement of commitment: “We were built to last, on until forever/The world is changing fast/But our love was built to last.” It’s a fitting finale to a thoroughly compelling album.